Nothing says summer in Ocean City, NJ quite like a cone in hand, sandy feet, and a walk along the boardwalk. Whether you’re visiting for a week or just down for the day, ice cream is basically a requirement.
But with so many options, where should you go?
We’ve rounded up the top 5 ice cream spots in Ocean City, NJ ranked by locals and frequent visitors so you know exactly where to satisfy your sweet tooth.
1. Kohr Bros Frozen Custard
Best for: Classic boardwalk custard
If you know, you know. Kohr Bros is a must-have Ocean City staple. Their frozen custard is smoother and richer than traditional ice cream, and nothing beats grabbing a cone on the boardwalk after a beach day.
📍 Boardwalk
👉 Local favorite: Orange & vanilla swirl
2. Kessel’s Korner
Best for: Homemade flavors + local favorite
Kessel’s is a go-to for locals looking for something a little less touristy. Their ice cream is rich, flavorful, and always hits the spot after dinner.
📍 2760 Asbury Ave
👉 Why locals love it: From hand-dipped ice cream to soft serve, milkshakes, and loaded sundaes, Kessel’s has something for everyone.
3. Hobby Horse Ice Cream Parlor
Best for: Old-school charm + huge menu
A true Ocean City classic. Hobby Horse has been around forever, and it shows in the best way. Tons of flavors, friendly service, and that nostalgic shore-town feel.
📍 800 Ocean Ave
👉 Don’t miss: Their specialty sundaes
4. Aunt Betty’s Ice Cream Shack
Best for: Simple, nostalgic ice cream
Aunt Betty’s is all about classic beach vibes. No frills, just good ice cream and a reliable stop for families year after year.
📍 2100 Asbury Ave and 4001 West Ave
👉 Perfect for: Both hard and soft-serve ice cream, Italian ice and homemade waffles, brownies and cookies.
5. Johnny B Goode Ice Cream Parlor
Best for: Fun atmosphere + dessert variety
Johnny B Goode brings the energy with a retro feel and tons of options from ice cream to full-on desserts. It’s a great spot to end the night, especially with kids.
📍 3339 West Ave
👉 Bonus: Great for groups with different dessert cravings
Local Tip: When to Go
-
After 7pm: Cooler temps, lively boardwalk vibe
-
Mid-afternoon: Expect longer lines
-
Weekdays: Slightly quieter than weekends
Make It Part of Your Stay
One of the best parts of staying in Ocean City is being close enough to walk (or bike!) to your favorite ice cream spot every night.
When you book the right rental, dessert runs become part of your routine, not something you have to plan around.
Looking for the perfect place to stay near the boardwalk?
Browse our Ocean City, NJ beach rentals and stay just steps from all your favorite sweet spots.
Final Scoop
Start with Kohr Bros, mix in a few local favorites like Kessel’s and Hobby Horse, and you’ve got yourself the perfect Ocean City summer.
Because let’s be honest - no beach vacation is complete without ice cream!